June 5, 2019 posted by

The public critic has been dismembered by two opposing forces: As such, he worked as both an insider and an observer, both documenting history, and facilitating in its unfoldment. Ironically, the user-generated reviews often feel more trustworthy than professional reviews, partly for 30 Although these sites are fed the same stories directly by PR departments. There are many different functions a popular music critic can fulfil. In fact, his articulate, enthusiastic support for Nirvana and other Seattle groups on the Sub Pop label helped to propel the culture to international prominence. Thackery and the Mediated Text:

Thackeray’s European sketch books: These are both discourses of truth. There is a cultural hierarchy involved in the field of criticism, a pecking order of seriousness and intent that helps confer different kinds of authority upon individual critics. Space does not allow more than a sampling of these responses within this thesis, although I have attempted to collate them all together in the appendix that follows the main body of text. Interview with author, I could not promise to get my facts straight—whatever the facts were—but I could attempt to be sincere in my recommendations and passions. To answer simply, the co-opted critic may not be as insightful, incisive or knowledgeable about their chosen critic [sic] as one who is not. Australian blogger Meg White does not think so.

The form under investigation here is specifically that of the popular tastemaker critic.

William Makepeace Thackeray – Wikipedia

Hanrahan, along with many others, argues that this is not beneficial to culture in the long term: The situation has changed in the last few thesiss, partly because ongoing digitisation of U. These include bespoke criticism— where the criticism is specifically tailored to suit both the music and audience.

Instead, I use my own history as a music critic, including many decisions of varying success that I have made in adapting to changing circumstances, as the basis on which to theorise various directions and strategies that popular music criticism has taken and might take in web 2.

alice thackray thesis

You do not know what to avoid and what to listen to, and you do not have the time to sort through it htackray even if you did, even with the numerous recommendations that come via friends on social network sites such as Facebook and algorithms on music streaming sites such as Spotify. As Berger and others have thackday out, there are many ways of critiquing music or art, or dance, and so forth.


(PDF) Jeremy Thackray Thesis | Jerry Thackray –

Perhaps that is a positive as it means that popular music criticism can take whatever form the writer chooses. It is not unusual for a music critic thackraj journalist to simultaneously be a performing or recording musician and to also take on some kind of role allce the music industry itself, such as a press agent, band manager, or label manager.

This capital is mutable, being highly dependent on trends and fashion. At that time the idea of sustaining a liveable career as a music critic was tenable and something I managed to achieve for over two decades.

He worsened matters by excessive eating and drinking, and avoiding exercise, though he enjoyed riding he kept a horse.

So yes, the goal of the music critic is to find and express the truth evoked by some musical artefact or phenomenon and hopefully inspire the reader to feel something along 33 McGee went on to live out his dreams of starting a record label. Interview with author, The decline in power of the tastemaker music critic in pre-web 2.

Archived from the original on 21 February If the craft of the music critic is to use language to convey the feeling and substance of music, one may question the value of that skill in a time when the reader can listen to the music directly.

I then provide an analysis of my early career path as a music critic, and triangulate that analysis with the career path of the popular music critic as exemplified by the critical discourse around rock and pop music that took place in various influential American and British print publications dating from the s onwards.

alice thackray thesis

The gig I reviewed had 12 people in attendance. When I started up my own magazine inCareless Talk Costs Lives, I noticed that, through our fledgling online message board and regular subscriber base, we had created our own audience, one that had not previously existed.

alice thackray thesis

These voices could all be agreeing on Facebook upon the latest screed from Pitchfork editor Jessica Hopper, which already happens. I have written several books about rock music, most notably biographies of Nirvana True,The White Stripes and Ramones, and have contributed chapters to several more. The thesis concludes that there are four major roles of relevance to the critic in the new media environments: Significantly, for rock and popular music culture, cultural capital is not accumulated through wealth or possessions but through symbolic capital, the aesthetic choices individuals make—for example, the music they listen to, the clothes they choose to wear, the magazines they read.


As an indication, Thurman Gillmor, ; Thurman,Lasica Brunset al and Delwiche directly address the shift from industrial journalism to citizen journalism that is occurring in web 2. In a paper analysing the political economy of the music press, with emphasis on the idea of criticism serving as a consumer guide, Fenster argues that Critical discourse […] enters into our everyday discourse with others, and into our own evaluation of music we hear on radio and television, as well as on our own stereos.

Is this circumstance achievable—or even desirable—in more democratised communication environments?

William Makepeace Thackeray

The Uses of Adversity, — So why then, would music journalists tgesis lamenting the death of the rock critic? I rapidly discovered this did not matter in the world of music criticism. This definitional confusion is viewed as unhelpful, and is something else this research project attempts to address.

To that end I conducted interviews with thirty music critics and used their responses to help ground and triangulate my observations and suggestions.

For the purposes of this study, I refer to the sociological approach described above as music criticism. Most often, the readers choose not to make it so. In an age where popular music is no longer considered the principal form of entertainment, popular music criticism thckray to take on various novel functions to establish its value and authority.

Hanrahan theorises that the erosion of cultural expertise made possible by the new technologies is democratic in at least one sense, in that there is broader participation in making and thakcray culture. Yet that has always been the case.